blog

Froyo is cool again. Here are our fave (frozen) sweet treats.

Written by Amy Rosner | Aug 19, 2025 3:22:00 PM

Pinkberry walked so the modern dessert era could run.

Back then, we were 14 — Nyx-glossed and emotionally invested in boys who didn’t wear deodorant.

Now? Dessert isn’t just a treat — it’s a calendar event. We plan outfits for it. Cross boroughs for it. Wait in lines like it’s a Cult Gaia sample sale.

And somehow, froyo made it out of the early 2010s alive. Better, actually. She’s rebranded — sleek, minimal and finally getting the respect she always deserved. Kind of like your Khaite-wearing mom who “just had good instincts.”

She’s older, hotter and knows her probiotic worth.

So here it is — a lineup of NYC frozen spots worth obsessing over.

The Riff: Softside

Website

Matcha Frozen Yogurt: Mimi's 

Website

Ballerina Farm Maple Cinnamon Soft Serve: Happier Grocery

Website

Dubai Chocolate Frozen Yogurt: Madison Fare

Website

Plain Greek Yogurt W/Sprinkles: Culture

Website

Peanut Butter Frozen Yogurt: Butterfield Market

 Website

Corn and Blueberry Soft Serve: Leo

Website

PB Oreo Crunch: Glace

Website

Passionfruit Olive Oil Cake Soft Serve:  Caffè Panna

Website

Cantaloupe Sorbet W/ Pistacchio Gelato: L’Industrie Pizzeria

Website

Salted Peanut Butter Soft Serve: Morgenstern's Bananas

Website

The O.G.: The Gyro Project

Website