blog

The Fluent guide to sipping in secret.

Written by Sarah Finkel | Sep 16, 2025 7:24:53 PM

The NYC bar scene can err on the side of being loud, crowded and a little too eager to hand you a $24 espresso martini. But if you know where to look – down unmarked staircases, behind anonymous doors, past neon distractions – the city still rewards discretion.

These aren’t the gimmicky “phone booth” speakeasies on every tourist’s bucket list. In fact, some of these aren’t speakeasies at all, rather, the bars that feel like secret societies in a hidden, insiders-only world.

Presenting the Paris-meets-Tokyo sanctuaries where the cocktails are art, the bartenders are the curateurs and the people are the kind who’d rather be in on the secret than seen in the scene.

Submercer

Social / Website

Experimental Cocktail Club

Social / Website

Employees Only

Website

People’s

Social / Website

Attaboy

Website

Lullaby

Social  / Website

Bar Nena

Website

Apotheke

Social / Website

Barlume Downstairs

Social / Website

Bar Goto

Website

Angel's Share

Social / Website

Maison Premiere

Social / Website

Fig. 19

Website

The Mulberry

Social / Website